Search results

Salaam Iyad, Privately send me the link where it says this. Please, privately send me this email. I'd like to have a look. Jazaakallah.

Re: whatever,why you closed the thread? I closed it cause I didnt care to see your "responde" after you had,being given a chance to clarify, said that you considered the Companions(May Allaah be pleased with them) as liars. Nothing good can come from you after such statements. The fact that...

GTv13, you were discussing this issue in the Hadith thread. I dont understand why you made this separate thread again. No need to repeat the whole thing again. GTv13 please read my last post. It has the answers there. Iyad, I suggest you read the thread especially some things he said in the end.

Thanks Brian. was wondering what to say.

Thats the problem. You dont know what you are talking about. you have not read and, thus, have not understood the great effort put in to authenticating the Sunnah. If you think you have made some sort of point, i dont see it. We are talking about muslims here, i dont know why you are talking...

salaam, regarding the website, I do not say that what is written is right and I dont say that its wrong. I suggest a good book rather than wikipedia. If you want to learn Islam, then do so from the authentic sources.

Im going to ask you this once only eventhough it seems pretty clear what you just said. When you say "Science of Hadith tells us that the people have to verife if any of the companions ever lied... " you mentioned "the companions"... this, among muslims, refers to the Companions of the Prophet...

h| Gtv13, I'd like you to answer a few questions as im interested in learning how you know these things. Please answer as briefly as possible but you must provide details of the source of your information so that I understand how you know. I'm sure you have other things to do, so i'll just ask...

I know why you wrote it. but you never seem to understand what im saying. Why do you forget what you have said. I quote your text so that you know why im saying something but you never seem to understand anything. What i wrote WAS the answer but you didnt understand it for some reason. That...

oh you never said it but you implied it alright.go back to where i quoted your text to which i replied. mainly to your saying "Do the verses have a different meaning in Arabic?" Prove your point.. not just tell us. Anyone here can tell you something. Yes, it IS your own personal interpretation...

GTv13, are you going to tell me and everyone here that each word in arabic has only one meaning? A word can have many meanings. Why choose one over the other? but we can get to that once you have proven your point, which you havent. And uve ignored the rest of what I said. I find your...

h| Green and welcome to CR. Just wondering... who is your twin brother here?

Then, just like that, ther is no way, anyone can claim that Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) meant only the Muslims either cause the unbelieving Quraish did treat the Quran as the verse says. Oh and btw, by saying "as far as I understand." you are admitting that your methodology of interpreting the Qur'an...

I wont waste time trying to show you how 'my people' can refer to the unbelieving Quraish. Why? cause as far as i can see, you are contradicting your first explanation of 'my people'. First you said it referred to the Muslims. Now, you say that it doesnt mean just the Quraish implying that 'my...

h| GTv13, I've been following this discussion and i have to say that i havent seen anything compelling from you GTv13. Everything you say is based on personal interpretation of verses. for the sake of argument, if your opponents are not allowed to use hadith, then they can easily say that these...

I repeat: Please try not to mix culture with Islam. you might end up confusing others with your use of the term 'Islamic culture'. Please lets not complicate a simple matter. We are talking Islam here. Yes Islamic teachings has its influence on these countries but its not necessary that every...

Please try not to mix culture with Islam. I know its difficult for you to make out the difference. Taliban does not equal Islam. And just cause western culture loves music and Islam prohibits it, doesnt make muslims barbaric/bonkers/crazy. It doesnt matter if people accept it or not. This isnt...

Most welcome Bandit. I assume from your questions, that you have not seen people praying in a mosque. I suggest a visit. Easier to see it, than to explain it. Still not sure about ur use of the word 'order' because you said "with some type of order" instead of saying "in some type of order"...

H| Bandit, i dont want to swamp you, so i'll be concise. Firstly, i must confess that i dont understand when you say 'outside the religion'. If you mean 'outside the mosque', then I would explicitly tell you that islam does not start and stop at the mosque. The ruling is general and applies at...

h| bandit, Use of musical instruments is haram [forbidden], so what to speak of its use in prayer. You can check out the recent Music thread; the info contained in it is enough. Bottom line: No musical instruments. The latter part of your question requires some time. there is a rule in all this...