Lux
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 319
- Reaction score
- 92
- Points
- 28
I'll start a new thread here, for my questions to you will be mostly about your religion - Islam.
Do you apply the same view to the Quran too? Forgive my ignorance and super-basic questions as I have no knowledge of it ... I think the traditional belief says that the Quran was written by Mohammed (even tho I'm not Muslim, is it a good-manner to add 'PBUH' after prophets' names when speaking with a Muslim? Or it's only required for Muslims to do so?) and he was dictated(?) to by an angel ... But how do Muslim scholars/academics see who the author(s) was(were)?
Also this negative stereotypical view of Islam (Sorry, I'm sure you're tired of hearing this) that it teaches to convert all others to Islam or kill those who refuse to convert ... Is this type of teaching written in the Quran? (I won't be surprised though, Deuteronomy says pretty much the same.) But clearly good peaceful Muslims are not following that. How do you determine which parts of the Quran you'd follow and which parts you don't? And lastly, do you believe one has to be a Muslim to go to heaven?
[EDIT: Addition]
I just noticed you've placed a big post explaining Islam. Perhaps the answers to my questions are in there. I'll take a read.
To comment on your statements however, Muslims aren't the decendents of Ishmael (PBUH). Mouhammed (PBUH) is a decendant of him. As for the OT. We view (as doctrine) it as a book that contains the words of God. It is Holy because of this. We do believe however that amongst the words of God there are words of man. And that some of these words are contradictory of Gods and is at times inpossible to discern God's word (and commands) from that of the man (or woman) who wrote it.
Do you apply the same view to the Quran too? Forgive my ignorance and super-basic questions as I have no knowledge of it ... I think the traditional belief says that the Quran was written by Mohammed (even tho I'm not Muslim, is it a good-manner to add 'PBUH' after prophets' names when speaking with a Muslim? Or it's only required for Muslims to do so?) and he was dictated(?) to by an angel ... But how do Muslim scholars/academics see who the author(s) was(were)?
Also this negative stereotypical view of Islam (Sorry, I'm sure you're tired of hearing this) that it teaches to convert all others to Islam or kill those who refuse to convert ... Is this type of teaching written in the Quran? (I won't be surprised though, Deuteronomy says pretty much the same.) But clearly good peaceful Muslims are not following that. How do you determine which parts of the Quran you'd follow and which parts you don't? And lastly, do you believe one has to be a Muslim to go to heaven?
[EDIT: Addition]
I just noticed you've placed a big post explaining Islam. Perhaps the answers to my questions are in there. I'll take a read.
Last edited: