Illuminationist Pilosophy, the Bahai Faith, and Resurrection

Ahanu

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,248
Reaction score
550
Points
108
Here I will discuss the meaning of rising from the dead from the Baha’i perspective.


From what I understand, Shaykh Ahmad al-Ahsa'i taught the teachings of the Ishraqi school of Shi'i Islam. The Arabic term Ishraq means "rising from the sun." It is also known as Illuminationist philosophy, which will be important for the study of the resurrection. Illuminationist philosophy began with Al-Suhrawardi, who was born in 1155. I still do not fully understand it. The following links are good reads for those unfamiliar with Illuminationist philosophy, like me:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illuminationist_philosophy

http://www.muslimphilosophy.com/ip/rep/H054.htm

http://www.reference.com/browse/Illuminationist+philosophy?jss=1

http://www.muslimphilosophy.com/ip/rep/H031.htm

http://www.ismaili.net/mirrors/Ikhwan_05/h004.html
"Perhaps the most enduring and influential school of mystical philosophy in Islam came into being in the sixth century ah (twelfth century ad) with Shihab al-Din al-Suhrawardi, who founded the school of ishraq or Illumination. Al-Suhrawardi's basic premise was that knowledge is available to man not through ratiocination alone but also, and above all, through illumination resulting from the purification of one's inner being. He founded a school of philosophy which some have called theosophy in its original sense, that is, mystical philosophy through and through but without being against logic or the use of reason. In fact, al-Suhrawardi criticized Aristotle and the Muslim Peripatetics on logical grounds before setting about expounding the doctrine of ishraq. This doctrine is based not on the refutation of logic, but of transcending its categories through an illuminationist knowledge based on immediacy and presence, or what al-Suhrawardi himself called 'knowledge by presence' (al-'ilm al-huduri), in contrast to conceptual knowledge (al-'ilm al-husuli) which is our ordinary method of knowing based on concepts (Ha'iri Yazdi 1992)."
Anyway, there is an Imaginal World or World of Image in the Ishraqi school.
"About half a century earlier than Ibn ‘Arabi (d.1240), Suhrawardi introduced his own independent ‘imaginal world’, what Corbin has called the mundus imaginalis, a fourth ‘imaginal’ world, alongside the intelligible, the spiritual and the material. This imaginal world, a substance made of shadows, operates like an ‘isthmus’ or an intermediary realm between the world of pure light and the physical world of darkness, lying somewhere between this physical world and the world of the species and of Platonic Forms (the horizontal lights), perhaps at the lower threshold of the world of souls.

In the imaginal world, entities somehow possess an existence of their own (some, prior to their coming into existence in this world). The imaginal world contains images that are not embedded in matter, a plane of “ghosts, of the forms in mirrors, dreams, and worlds of wonder beyond our own” which light can existentiate (Walbridge 2000: 26). The imaginal world provides the material for the miraculous. It is where the ‘metahistorical’ (Corbin's term) visions of Imams occur, where eschatological forms and images will perhaps be existentiated for the souls of the deceased, so that they may continue to perfect their souls (PI, 148.29-150.17), as well as where elements not fitting conveniently into the Aristotelian scheme of forms in matter are found. Suhrawardi did not, however, systematically develop the concept. This was left to his followers."

http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/suhrawardi/
It is in the Imaginal World that Joseph, for instance, receives the images he REALLY saw in his dreams (Genesis 37: 5-7; 9). Later, this reality was reflected in the physical world. The book of Matthew records an event in which Jesus led his disciples up a mountain, where the three disciples had an epiphany. Moses and Elijah appeared before them. Shall they stay? It is Peter who wished to build a shelter for Jesus, Moses, and Elijah (Matthew 17:14). Suddenly, a cloud “enveloped them,” and then Moses and Elijah disappeared (Mark 9:7-8). While coming down the mountain, Jesus instructed them not to tell anyone what they had seen until Jesus “has been raised from the dead” (Matthew 17: 9). Perhaps Moses and Elijah are in the World of Image, and then Moses and Elijah were reflected in the physical world through Jesus, a Moses-figure, and John, who they now believe to be Elijah? If so, we have the resurrection of Moses, as the Baha'i Faith teaches. Ah, it is sketchy, but you see where I am going with this one!
 
Is the World of Images equivalent to Abdul-Baha's concept of the "World of Visions?"
 
Linking the World of Image with Shaykh Ahmad

Al-Suhrawardi's Illuminationist philosophy contains elements (like believing the essence of God could be known) that the Báb would consider heretical. The World of Image idea is called "hūrqalyā" by Shaykh Ahmad al-Ahsa'i, and is further developed, I think.
According to Aḥsāʾī, the term Hūrqalyā, which he uses for the interworld between earth and malakūt, is a Syriac term in use among the Sabeans of Iraq. Hūrqalyā is situated in the eighth clime; its lower regions are the cities of Jābalqā and Jābarsā, and it is, in its entirety, the world of images and forms. The Qāʾem dwells in Hūrqalyā and will return from there (“Resāla Mollā Moḥammad-Ḥosayn An ṣ ārī” in Jawāmeʿ al-kalem I/3, pp. 8-10 [153-54]; “Resāla-ye Raštīya,” ibid., I/2, pp. 68-114, question 28).
Encyclopaedia Iranica





 
Is the World of Images equivalent to Abdul-Baha's concept of the "World of Visions?"

Hi Ahanu, What is your source for the "world of visions" in 'Abdu'l-Baha's Writings?
 
Re: Linking the World of Image with Shaykh Ahmad

Al-Suhrawardi's Illuminationist philosophy contains elements (like believing the essence of God could be known) that the Báb would consider heretical. The World of Image idea is called "hūrqalyā" by Shaykh Ahmad al-Ahsa'i, and is further developed, I think.


Yes, but hurqalya is not a term that the Bab used.
 
Here I will discuss the meaning of rising from the dead from the Baha’i perspective.

I don't see what the relationship between these passages from Suhrawardi and the Baha'i perspective of the life of the soul or life after death. Can you please explain?

Regarding the 'alam al-mithal, in one of His Tablets, Baha'u'llah identified the realm of malakut (also known as the Kingdom of Abha) situated between the realms of nasut and jabarut as being the 'alam al-mithal mentioned in the works of the philosophers. He went on to say that everything in the heavens and on the earth has its counterpart in this realm.
 
Hi Ahanu, What is your source for the "world of visions" in 'Abdu'l-Baha's Writings?
"Arise and wash thy body, wear a pure gown, and directing thyself to the Kingdom of God, supplicate and pray to Him. Sleep in a clean, well prepared and ventilated place, and ask for appearance (or display) in the world of vision. Thou wilt have visions which will cause the doors of doubts to be closed, which will five you new joy, wonderful dilation, brilliant glory. Thou wilt comprehend realities and meanings."
Bahá'í Reference Library - Tablets of Abdul-Baha Abbas, Pages 672-673
 
Re: Linking the World of Image with Shaykh Ahmad

Yes, but hurqalya is not a term that the Bab used.

Surely he is familiar with the idea.
During his [the Bab's] seclusion in Karbala, he attended now and then the classes of Haji Sayyid Kasem, with a shining and luminous countenance. Whenever he entered the class, Haji Sayyid Kasem would show him the greatest respect and honor."
(Munirih Khanum quoting her uncle, found in Episodes in the Life of Moneereh Khanum, pp. 11-12) Sayyid Kazim Rashti - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Sayyid Kazim, the successor of Shaykh Ahmad, met with the Bab. They must of discussed the World of Image at some point. As I currently understand it, resurrection occurs in this realm and is reflected in the physical world.

The Bab said:
For example, from the inception of the mission of Jesus—may peace be upon Him—till the day of His ascension was the Resurrection of Moses.

From the World of Image, Moses was reflected in the physical world and was actually there during Jesus' ministry. The disciples were given a glimpse of this reality. Those are my speculations.
 
Can you please explain?

Sure . . . but only after I read more on it, so that I will have a better understanding of it.
 
Baha'u'llah's term for the World of Image is 'Alam al-Mithal.

Click in the link below to see where he uses the term in his writings.

http://bahai-library.org/uhj/images/1.big.gif

The next link below contains the definition to 'Alam al-Mithalm, which is the same as the one above from Illuminationist Philosophy.

'Alam al-Mithal: "The imaginal realm, which is also known as the realm of souls, is higher than the realm of the visible ('alam al-shahadat) and lower than the realm of spirits. The realm of the visible is the shadow of the imaginal realm which, inturn, is the shadow of the realm of spirits. Everything that exists in this world exist also in the imaginal realm, that which is seen in dreams being a form of the imaginal realm. In the Kashf al-Lughat it states that the absolute imaginal realm is the realm of spirits, while the relative imaginal realm is the realm of imagination (khayal)." (Tahanawi [Nurbakhsh tr.], Kashshaf Istilahat al-Funun, 1342)

http://74.6.146.127/search/cache?ei=UTF-8&p=realm+of+malakut&fr=yfp-t-501&u=bahai-library.com/%3Ffile%3Dmccarron_symbolic_cosmology_sufism&w=realm+realms+malakut&d=YSVlUkxISpEI&icp=1&.intl=us
It is clear that this is the World of Image or the collective unconsciousness, as Jung would call it. These spirits in the World of Image would have an astral body, as I found on wikipedia.
"Buddhists from Tibet talk of the bardo realm in which many states of the spirit/soul, i.e. bardos, exist between lifetimes on earth. The Spiritualists in their teachings call it the Spirit World, following the great visionary Swedenborg....In the Celtic tradition, the intermediary realm is often called the Middle Kingdom or the Faery World. Australian aborigines call it the Dreamtime, the Sufis of Persia called it the alam al-mithal or Mythic World, which Henry Corbin (1995) has dubbed the mundus imaginalis. Jung called it the collective unconscious....."

Astral body - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Now I have to find how this ties in with the resurrection and the Baha'i Faith. Hmm . . . I'm bored today and have nothing to do, so I have time to search right now (hehe).
 
Out-of-body experiences happen once the subtle body/dream body/astral body leaves the physical body to travel into higher realms above the physical world. I can't help but think of this phrase: "I see dead people." In the subtle body one can communicate with those who have passed away in the physical world. Abdul-Baha said:

T[SIZE=-1]HE[/SIZE] W[SIZE=-1]ORLD OF[/SIZE] V[SIZE=-1]ISION[/SIZE]
[SIZE=-1][/SIZE]​
As to the question whether the souls will recognize each other in the spiritual world: This fact is certain; for the Kingdom is the world of vision where all the concealed realities will become disclosed. How much more the well-known souls will become manifest. The mysteries of which man is heedless in this earthly world, those he will discover in the heavenly world, and there will he be informed of the secret of truth; how much more will he recognize or discover persons with whom he hath been associated. Undoubtedly, the holy souls who find a pure eye and are favored with insight will, in the kingdom of lights, be acquainted with all mysteries, and will seek the bounty of witnessing the reality of every great soul. Even they will manifestly behold the Beauty of God in that world. Likewise will they find all the friends of God, both those of the former and recent times, present in the heavenly assemblage.

Bahá'í World Faith: Chapter 8
The World of Image . . .
is an isthmus (barzakh), world of the Kingdom (malakut) and the plane where all visionary, mystical, eschatological and initial after-death experiences occur. As such, on this level "bodies are spiritualized and spirits corporealized68."
UHJ Letter: research-dept.alam.html

OK. I could not find anything that mentioned resurrection and the World of Image specifically, but I think that the World of Image=World of Visions.

Abdul-Baha said the following in Paris Talks that relates to the subject of resurrection:

The soul has two main faculties. (a) As outer circumstances are communicated to the soul by the eyes, ears, and brain of a man, so does the soul communicate its desires and purposes through the brain to the hands and tongue of the physical body, thereby expressing itself. The spirit in the soul is the very essence of life. (b) The second faculty of the soul expresses itself in the world of vision, where the soul inhabited by the spirit has its being, and functions without the help of the material bodily senses. There, in the realm of vision, the soul sees without the help of the physical eye, hears without the aid of the physical ear, and travels without dependence upon physical motion. It is, therefore, clear that the spirit in the soul of man can function through the physical body by using the organs of the ordinary senses, and that it is able also to live and act without their aid in the world of vision. This proves without a doubt the superiority of the soul of man over his body, the superiority of spirit over matter.

Paris Talks PART I
So here in this world of vision the soul sees events (such as the resurrection). Now I know why the Bab says the day of resurrection is like any other day, and it is often that people do not see it; all of this takes place in the realm of vision, as Abdul-Baha would say.
 
Regarding the 'alam al-mithal, in one of His Tablets, Baha'u'llah identified the realm of malakut (also known as the Kingdom of Abha) situated between the realms of nasut and jabarut as being the 'alam al-mithal mentioned in the works of the philosophers. He went on to say that everything in the heavens and on the earth has its counterpart in this realm.

It appears so.
 
"Arise and wash thy body, wear a pure gown, and directing thyself to the Kingdom of God, supplicate and pray to Him. Sleep in a clean, well prepared and ventilated place, and ask for appearance (or display) in the world of vision. Thou wilt have visions which will cause the doors of doubts to be closed, which will five you new joy, wonderful dilation, brilliant glory. Thou wilt comprehend realities and meanings."

Thanks for the link. It would be helpful to see what the original locution is in the Persian or Arabic. Baha'u'llah has similar Tablets on dreams.
 
Re: Linking the World of Image with Shaykh Ahmad

Surely he is familiar with the idea.

I didn't say He wasn't but He chose what to talk about in His revelation and despite the thousands of pages that He wrote, He chose not to talk about hurqalya nor about the elaborate system of subtle/material bodies that Shaykh Ahmad devotes so much attention to in his treatises nor about many other things prevalent in the Shi'i milieu of His time.

The Bab said:
For example, from the inception of the mission of Jesus—may peace be upon Him—till the day of His ascension was the Resurrection of Moses.

From the World of Image, Moses was reflected in the physical world and was actually there during Jesus' ministry. The disciples were given a glimpse of this reality. Those are my speculations.

My own humble understanding of this is that the spiritual Reality, the qualities and attributes of Moses, were resurrected and returned when Jesus appeared. The appearance of Jesus was likewise the Day of Judgment for the followers of Moses. Those who could recognized Moses in His resurrected form - as Jesus - and chose to abide by the teachings of Christ entered the paradise of Jesus' presence. Those who rejected Moses in His resurrected form were cast into hell of remoteness. The Bab explains -- in particular in the Persian Bayan -- that the same process is repeated at the appearance of every Manifestation of God.
 
Images

In my opinion, I think I have just found different ways of saying the same thing. The place of no place, world of pure images, or whatever else it is called, contains images which have an immaterial materiality. To be able to see theses images and understand them, one must look with spiritual eyes.

For example: the dawn of the sun in the the world of pure images represents the appearance of the Manifestation of God in the physical world. This image is an archetype in the sense that it contains recognizable patterns that activate other archetypes, like the resurrection.

Well, I guess that is all I have to say on the subject.
 
Greetings!

Please bear in mind that Paris Talks is not Baha'i scripture.

As to Resurrection, Baha'is see it as a spiritual event, and our scriptures (specifically, The Book of Certitude) describe the Judgement Day as referring to the time when a new Divine Messanger is on earth. Resurrection has to do with acceptance of a Messenger.

Peace,

Bruce
 
Back
Top