William Stoddart

Thomas

So it goes ...
Veteran Member
Messages
14,952
Reaction score
4,640
Points
108
Location
London UK
A notable perennialist, William Stoddart, passed in November last year; he was 98 years old.

Born in Carstairs, Scotland. Raised a Protestant, he discovered Eastern spirituality through his father, who traveled to India. He developed an interest in religions, once saying: "It never for a moment entered my head that these religions could be false. I knew instinctively that they were true, but had no idea at the time just how much the doctrine of 'the transcendent unity of the religions‘ was going to mean for me in later life. I should add that this intuition of the validity of the non-Christian religions in no way weakened my attachment to Christianity."

Aged 20, Stoddart discovered the writings of Ananda Coomaraswamy and through him learned about René Guénon, Frithjof Schuon and Titus Burckhardt.

He recognised the many advocates of the philosophia perennis, but himself would assert that these were the most significant. He constantly reminded serious seekers that one needed to read and re-read the writings of Schuon in particular as a way to recognise the supra-formal truth at the heart of all religions. He retired in 1982 from a career in medical research and relocated to America to live near his spiritual mentor, Frithjof Schuon.

Stoddart was an award-winning author and editor. He was assistant editor of Studies in Comparative Religion, a British journal dedicated to publishing writings on the perennial philosophy. He was a board member in the early days of the Matheson Trust, which promotes the philosophical, metaphysical, cosmological, and aesthetic study of all traditions. One of Stoddart‘s gifts was his capacity to distill complex and voluminous information into direct and succinct language, for which reason he was regarded as a master of synthesis.

In paying tribute to the life and work of the English Catholic writer Bernard Kelly, Stoddart recalls a telling statement about Kelly that could just as easily have applied to himself: – There are some of us who can‘t rightly pray without a pen in our hands.

Stoddart saw that it was not enough to simply affirm diverse religious manifestations and their unity, but that we needed to pursue a salvific path whole-heartedly: We must be capable of the cardinally important intuition that every religion, Christianity, Hinduism, Buddhism, or Islam, comes from God and every religion leads back to God.

The wide range of Stoddart‘s writings include Sufism, Hinduism and Buddhism. He translated several traditionalist works from the original French and German: Esoterism as Principle and as Way and Sufism: Veil and Quintessence as well as over 3000 poems by Schuon. He also translated Titus Burckhardt: Alchemy: Science of the Cosmos, Science of the Soul, and Mirror of the Intellect: Essays on Traditional Science and Sacred Art as well as editing The Essential Titus Burckhardt: Reflections on Sacred Art, Faiths, and Civilizations.

He never tired of reminding people that, in Schuon‘s opus, there was everything necessary to sustain our spiritual journey back to the Divine, yet we needed first and foremost to be rooted in one of the authentic revealed spiritual traditions that have been bequeathed to humanity. It is through the doorway of tradition that we may apprehend the unanimity to be found among all the great religions.

Verily we belong to God and unto Him we shall return (Qurʼān 2:152)

(Précis of In Memoriam by Samuel Bendeck Sotillos, from "Transcendent Philosophy: An International Journal for Comparative Philosophy and Mysticism" essay here)
 
He never tired of reminding people that, in Schuon‘s opus, there was everything necessary to sustain our spiritual journey back to the Divine, yet we needed first and foremost to be rooted in one of the authentic revealed spiritual traditions that have been bequeathed to humanity. It is through the doorway of tradition that we may apprehend the unanimity to be found among all the great religions.

Verily we belong to God and unto Him we shall return (Qurʼān 2:152)

(Précis of In Memoriam by Samuel Bendeck Sotillos, from "Transcendent Philosophy: An International Journal for Comparative Philosophy and Mysticism" essay here)
Mmm .. we will all return to our Maker .. and He will judge between us at the appointed time.
 
I think the Perennialist distinction is between an active or passive returnee.
 
"It never for a moment entered my head that these religions could be false. I knew instinctively that they were true, but had no idea at the time just how much the doctrine of 'the transcendent unity of the religions‘ was going to mean for me in later life. I should add that this intuition of the validity of the non-Christian religions in no way weakened my attachment to Christianity."
This reminds me of Unity Church, which to me seemed like a common-man's school of comparative religion.
(Or a common man's school of perennialism)
 
This reminds me of Unity Church, which to me seemed like a common-man's school of comparative religion.
(Or a common man's school of perennialism)
Perennialists would, I think, take issue with these types of denomination for what evidences, as they would perceive it, a failure to observe fundamental metaphysical distinctions – a religious syncretism without understanding the principles of the traditions borrowed from.

The over-arching influence was the New Thought school which flourished in America in the 19th century. It has its origins in 'Mesmerism' (Franz Anton Mesmer, 1734-1815) which found its way to the US and was championed by Phineas Parkhurst Quimby (1802-1866).

From there, any number of schools blossomed in short order, Unity being one.

Regarding Christian Nationalism, as being discussed elsewhere, I think this is a fundamental example. They're all about self-help, self-cure, the idea that illness rises in the mind, and is cured there ... and the Prosperity Gospel is almost an inversion of New Testament principles put to work in pursuit of The American Dream.

It's re-emerging in MAGA.
 
The over-arching influence was the New Thought school which flourished in America in the 19th century. It has its origins in 'Mesmerism' (Franz Anton Mesmer, 1734-1815) which found its way to the US and was championed by Phineas Parkhurst Quimby (1802-1866).
Also Transcendentalism I believe
Regarding Christian Nationalism, as being discussed elsewhere, I think this is a fundamental example. They're all about self-help, self-cure, the idea that illness rises in the mind, and is cured there ... and the Prosperity Gospel is almost an inversion of New Testament principles put to work in pursuit of The American Dream.
I didn't know Christian Nationalism was about self help and the idea that illness arises in the mind. That actually sounds more like New Thought, including Unity, though more profoundly in Christian Science or Religious Science. Christian Nationalism was, I thought, more solidly this world and politically driven.
 
I didn't know Christian Nationalism was about self help and the idea that illness arises in the mind. That actually sounds more like New Thought, including Unity, though more profoundly in Christian Science or Religious Science. Christian Nationalism was, I thought, more solidly this world and politically driven.
I think it arrives there as part of process, but it seems to me the underlying factor is 'self-help', 'self-made', self-reliance', it's an ideology that's written into the Constitution, it's what shaped New Thought in its incarnation, it's what has led to where we are today; it underpins consumer culture.
 
I think it arrives there as part of process, but it seems to me the underlying factor is 'self-help', 'self-made', self-reliance', it's an ideology that's written into the Constitution, it's what shaped New Thought in its incarnation, it's what has led to where we are today; it underpins consumer culture.
Interesting thesis: the light and dark sides of individualism.
 
Back
Top