Muslimwoman
Coexistence insha'Allah
--> But it seems that there are women who work in the outside world, as well as ‘stay-home moms’. So, perhaps two sets of rules should be considered?
Indeed there are and some of them wear niqab. Niqab is a choice, if your lifestyle is such that niqab is a burden or causes you problems then you can choose not to wear it.
--> I agree. But do you feel Martin Luther King was right or wrong in breaking society’s rules, and getting so much attention in doing so?
MLK had a point to make, something to fight against ... I don't so why would I need to break any rules or draw attention to myself?
I could agree with you if I visited somewhere like Afghanistan, because I am beligerant I would probably remove my niqab just to make a point (probably get beaten up too lol).
--> True. The problem is mainly men chasing after women, not vice versa. But I think this is a case of what I call "20 mile-per-hour mentality." Thousands of people die in traffic accidents every year. We could pass a law limiting all vehicles to a speed of 20 miles per hour. That would save thousands of lives, wouldn’t it? Isn’t this the same logic as wearing a niqab?
Bad choice of analogy really as many town in the UK are introducing 20 MPH speed limits precicely to reduce RTA deaths. Maybe that is the difference, in the West we wait for something to go wrong and then try to fix it ... in Islam we try to fix it before it goes wrong ... conservative yes ... restrictive yes .... effective I believe so.
--> Would you be willing to agree that some women do not wear a niqab in order to please Allah? Would you agree that they have every right to do and feel so?
Indeed I do agree, some women are forced to wear it, some wear it to hide their unIslamic behaviour, others wear it because they are not beautiful but would like the world to think they are, many wear it simply because it pleases their husband, some wear it purely as a political statement and of course some wear it for Allah (swt) and the only one I would object to are the women forced to wear it (like Taliban Afghanistan).
--> And this issue is slowly disappearing as more women go out into society, as I discussed before.
A lot more slowly in Mid East countries but again, it is a choice (for most) a decision women can make for themselves and their lifestyle.
I refuse to accept the idea that the only answer to the problem is the niqab, and I get the feeling from some Muslims that the only answer they will consider is wearing a niqab.
I don't think you are being argumentative at all, I think you are being very respectful and it's nice for a change to be asked questions rather than told what I think or be told I have stockholm syndrome.
Of course I understand that niqab is not the right choice for everyone and why people probably think I'm nuts or indoctrinated for choosing to wear it but what I try to do is get people to stop using mental stereotypes of oppressed women too scared to speak out .. I used to believe that until I went to live among them.
No it is not the only answer, certainly men in the Middle East need to grow up a bit and stop blaming women for their silly obsession with opposite sex, the term "take a cold shower" springs to mind but can you accept that for the majority of women who choose to wear niqab it is an answer that works for them?