Question

Pico

Well-Known Member
Messages
273
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
California
How do those Muslims who think if you kill an infidel then you're guaranteed access to heaven justify such a beleif?
 
Islam does not allow a Muslim to kill an infidel for nothing

How do those Muslims who think if you kill an infidel then you're guaranteed access to heaven justify such a beleif?

Islam does not allow a Muslim to kill an infiel for nothing in the time of peace when there is no declared war already in progress. Islam is a religion of peace and unlike other religions its Book, Quran, is full of bright arguments so its followers need not kill who don't believe Islam or wage a war against them, in fact Islam prospers in the time of peace as then Muslims are afforded oppurtunity to win over other religions with arguments and Quran is full of those arguements. Islam being a rational religion allows to defend Muslims in special circumstances when the enemies don't let them live in peace and have attacked them and that only with certain conditions. This is clearly mentioned in Quran:
[22:40] Permission to take up arms is given to those against whom war is made, because they have been wronged and Allah, indeed, has power to help them. -
022-040.gif

[22:41] Those who have been driven out from their homes unjustly, only because they said, 'Our Lord is Allah.' And if Allah had not repelled some people by means of others, cloisters and churches and synagogues and mosques, wherein the name of Allah is oft remembered, would surely have been destroyed. And Allah will, surely, help him who helps Him. Allah is, indeed, Powerful, Mighty -
022-041.gif
[22:42] Those who, if We establish them in the earth, will observe Prayer and pay the Zak›t and enjoin good and forbid evil. And with Allah rests the final issue of all affairs.
022-042.gif

Thanks
I am an Ahmadi - a peaceful faith in Islam
 
How do those Muslims who think if you kill an infidel then you're guaranteed access to heaven justify such a beleif?

Hi Pico

As I have never met anyone who subscribes to this belief then I really can't answer your question. I would imagine they suffer the same sort of blindness as those people who burnt witches or the miriad of other attrocities that have been done in the name of Religions that say, do not kill or only fight if you are attacked.
 
Doesn't it say something about killing Christians and Jews in the Quran?

I think it's Surah 5:51, and 9:5
 
Doesn't it say something about killing Christians and Jews in the Quran?

I think it's Surah 5:51, and 9:5

Surah 5:51 says nothing about killing Christians and Jews.

I suggest that you read Surah 9:5 in context in order to understand it.

Are you just stirring or do you have a serious enquiry about Islams attitude to watfare and violent conflict?
 
Surah 5:51 says nothing about killing Christians and Jews.

I suggest that you read Surah 9:5 in context in order to understand it.

Are you just stirring or do you have a serious enquiry about Islams attitude to watfare and violent conflict?


This is a serious inquiry. Muslims claiming Allah commanded them to kill all infidels is a serious matter.
 
Hello Pico.

When the Holy Qur'an was revealed its followers were ostricized, attacked, killed, raped, driven out of their homes. First followers of Islam in Arabia endured great tribulations because they proclaimed belief in One God (Allah=The God, alluding only to the Oness of One God) and denounced the idols. Later, God the Merciful ALLOWED Muslims to defend themselves. Defending themselves meant killing those who intended to kill them.

Qur'an was not given all at once, but over a long period of time (10+ years). Chapter by chapter. Each chapter relfects its historical time and the contexts. Each ayat (statement) from the Qur'an that speaks of war and war activities reflects the situations Muslims found themselves in.

You will find that even in the Holy Bible (the Old Testament) God orders Israelites how to behave in war situations. In some cases rather harshly it is described that Israelites should do some acts of killing towards the unbelieving people (i.e. kill all women, elderly and children, not to leave anything alive).

In the case of Muslims, Qur'an does not speak of immmediate attack on the people who simply reject the Truth. Rather, it presents Muslims with the fact that they should try peacefuly to part ways from the unbelievers. Finally, if they are attacked and their freedom to practice Islam is shaken, they have right to defend themselves and to fight back.

Some among the Muslims use certain Qur'anic statements to pursue their own agendas, but ignore the fact that if no one is attacking them, they should not cause mischief first at all.

In todays time, we must objectively take a look at the world politics and events, and determine the following: 1) who is/was attacked first, 2) whose believes are threatened simply because of the religion, 3) what is the meaning of the wars? Perhaps some more questions.

Another thing to consider is that while the majority of the world peoples individualized themselves through the political/geographic borders between them. Muslim countries did the same, but the islamic consciousness of the Muslims is still one. That is why we see today that Muslims are feeling attacked everywhere when a country with majority Muslim population is being attacked.
 
but the islamic consciousness of the Muslims is still one.

nonsense. for all the talk about the 'umma, you only have to look on the "sunni vs shi'a" thread, or at anything where people are discussing ahmadiyya, ismailis, salafiyyah or sufism, to see just how little that appears to fit the facts. look at the sectarian violence in iraq. islamic consciousness is very clearly fragmented - when people talk about this they seem rather to mean "people who agree with me". in that there's not much difference between islam and other faiths.

b'shalom

bananabrain
 
This is a serious inquiry. Muslims claiming Allah commanded them to kill all infidels is a serious matter.

That is not an answer to the question that I posted.

I asked if you were making a serious enquiry or were just attempting to stir up conflict.
 
pico,

Here is Islam's Attitude towards war:

"Fight in the way of God against those who fight you, but do not go beyond limits. God does not love those who go beyond limits" [Quran, 2:190]

"Allah does not forbid you to be kind ( tabarru, birr) and equitable (tuqsitu, qist) to those who had neither fought against your faith nor driven you out of your homes. In fact Allah loves the equitable. (60:8) Allah only forbids you to make friends (wali) those who fought you on account of your faith and drove you out of your homes and backed up others in your expulsion. Those who will take them for friends are indeed the wrongdoers." ( Quran, 60: 9)


The above Quranic verses show that Muslims are only allowed to fight in self-defense against those who fight them.

And here are the ethics of war:

"...in Islam, the only wars that are permitted are between armies and they should engage on battle fields and engage nobly...The Prophet Muhammed [sm] said: "Do not kill women or children or non-combatants, and do not kill old people or religious people", and he mentioned priests, nuns and rabbi's. And he said "Do not cut down fruit bearing trees and do not poison the well of your enemies. ...". [Quote of Shiekh Hamza Yusuf, San Hose Mercury News, sep 15, 2001]

The Prophet [sm] adressed a Muslim army who were about to go to war, in the following terms:

"Go to war in adherance to the religion of God. Never touch the elderly, women or children. Allways improve their situation and be kind to them. God loves those who are sincere" [Ahmad, diya'al-Din. alKamushKhanawi, Ramuz al-Ahadith. vol 1, 84/8]

The Messenger of Allah [sm] also clarified the attitude a Muslim soldier must adopt, even in the middle of a raging battle, in the following terms:

"Do not kill children. avoid them people who devote themselves to worshiping in churches! Never murder women and the elderly. Do not set trees on fire or cut them down. Never destroy houses!" [Ahmad, Diya'al-Din alkamushKhanawi, Ramuz al-Ahadith, vol 1, 76/12]


In Sahih Bukhari, Book of Jihad, Chapter 147, hadith 257-258, it says:

"A woman was found killed during one of the Apostle of God's battles. so the Apostle of God forbade the killing of women and children"

Abu Bakar As-Siddique [ra], the first Caliph of Islam, and one of the rightly guided caliphs, gave the following command to his army before the first Syrian expedition:

"Stop O people, that I may give you ten rules to keep by heart: Do not commit treachery, nor depart from the right path. You must not mutilate, nither kill a child or aged man or woman. Do not destroy a palm tree, nor burn it with fire and do not cut a fruitfull tree. You must not slay any of the flock or herds or the camels, save for your subsistence. You are likely to pass by people who have devoted their lives to monastic services; leave them to that which they have devoted their lives. You are likely, likewise, to find people who will present to you meals of many kinds. You amy eat, but do not forget to mention the name of Allah". [Tabari, Ta' rikh, 1, 1850, cited in Majid Khadduri, War and Peace in the Law of Islam, John Hopkins Press, Balitmore, 1955, pg. 102]


Peace.
 
Ah, I see.

Question:

"Allah does not forbid you to be kind ( tabarru, birr) and equitable (tuqsitu, qist) to those who had neither fought against your faith nor driven you out of your homes. In fact Allah loves the equitable.


Does that mean "Eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth" kind of thing?

That was enlightening. Any idea as to how someone can think they are doing Allah's will by killing innocent, religious, or elderly people? Any passage that my be wretched out of context that might cause them to think that?
 
Ah, I see.

Question:



Does that mean "Eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth" kind of thing?

Well we have 'eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth' in our religion, but the above is reffering to defending from agression; this wouldn't fall under the catagory of 'eye for an eye' because it's not about retaliation, but it's about defence; e.g, if an enemy attacks you, then you have no choice but to defend yourself, or otherwise your going to be killed, injured, etc,

And regarding the 'eye for an eye' principle in our religion; Islam teaches that although we have a right for 'eye for an eye' as it serves the course of justice, yet it is better to forgive and forget and return good for evil, i.e, someone unjustly hits me, and I dont hit him back, but rather, when I see him another day, offer him a sweet and smile, etc,

That was enlightening. Any idea as to how someone can think they are doing Allah's will by killing innocent, religious, or elderly people? Any passage that my be wretched out of context that might cause them to think that?

only a verry tiny minority of muslim [0.1 percent?] extremists believe that 'eye for an eye' and 'defensive strategies' extends to the enemies civillians/innocents, in retaliation for the enemy killing the Muslim civillians/innocents, but the overwhelming vast majority of muslims [99.9 percent?] reject this and adhere to the correct interpretation of the Jihad verses and hadiths, that even if the enemy kill our civillians/innocents, were not allowed to kill theirs.

There's extremists in every religion, and if a person is hell-bent on being extreme, then he will put a corrupt interpretation to to the verry clear and unmistakable teachings of his religion, so it's not a matter of some Quranic verses or hadiths being easily interpretable in an extreme way, it's a just a matter of some people are deviants in their hearts and they will use the name of religion for their own ends.

hope that helps

Peace :)
 
What does it mean for a Christian or Jew to be "unclean"?

It means that they are spirtually impure, for they join partners with Allah by obeying their clergy that make what Allah [God] has made unlawfull, lawfull for them, and what Allah has made lawfull, unlawfull for them, so they basically take these priests, Rabbi's, etc, as their Lords besides God.

The Christians also join partners to Allah by attributing divinity to Jesus [pbuh] and the 'Holy Ghost'.

This concept that those who reject the true religion of God [and thus are astray/sinners] are spiritually impure, is not exclusive to the Islamic faith.

The Christians and jews regard people of other faiths to be spiritually impure as well, and I suppose the same could be said about the general major faiths out there.

Hope that helps

Peace. :)
 
It means that they are spirtually impure, for they join partners with Allah by obeying their clergy that make what Allah [God] has made unlawfull, lawfull for them, and what Allah has made lawfull, unlawfull for them, so they basically take these priests, Rabbi's, etc, as their Lords besides God.

Hey . . . come on.

What about the imams in Islam? Isn't local and earthly leadership a necessity? The common people don't always have time to study sacred texts, so special people are appointed, or dedicate themselves to do it as a living. When they have problems they go to the local priest, rabbi and imam for guidance and advice.

Pastors, presbyters, priests and rabbis are just like imams -- they are teachers and scholars. We don't worship them.

I don't consider my pastor to be "lord" as I seek a direct relationship with God.

The Christians also join partners to Allah by attributing divinity to Jesus [pbuh] and the 'Holy Ghost'.

I have heard that in Islam the Holy Ghost is the angel Gabriel.

Whether or not that is entirely true, it is not so in Christianity. In Christianity the Holy Ghost is God's own Spirit, which means it is essentially God Himself. The reason why the term "Holy Ghost" is used rather than simply "God" is to put God's spiritual influences in context. Christians don't worship an angel.

"Holy Ghost" doesn't mean the same thing in Islam and Christianity. Same name but completely different meanings.
 
Hey . . . come on.

What about the imams in Islam? Isn't local and earthly leadership a necessity? The common people don't always have time to study sacred texts, so special people are appointed, or dedicate themselves to do it as a living. When they have problems they go to the local priest, rabbi and imam for guidance and advice.

Pastors, presbyters, priests and rabbis are just like imams -- they are teachers and scholars. We don't worship them.

I don't consider my pastor to be "lord" as I seek a direct relationship with God.


I have heard that in Islam the Holy Ghost is the angel Gabriel.

Whether or not that is entirely true, it is not so in Christianity. In Christianity the Holy Ghost is God's own Spirit, which means it is essentially God Himself. The reason why the term "Holy Ghost" is used rather than simply "God" is to put God's spiritual influences in context. Christians don't worship an angel.

"Holy Ghost" doesn't mean the same thing in Islam and Christianity. Same name but completely different meanings.

Hi Saltmiester,

In Islam we have Imams and clerics who interpret the Quran and hadith for us, and we follow them, but what is meant by 'taking them as Lords' is when these 'Leaders' start allowing and prohibiting according to their own accord and not according to what God has revealed, then basically the followers attach to them an attribute which is only fit for God, which is that of the "law maker", and thus they take them as Lords.

Here is what Allah says in the Quran:

They have taken as lords beside Allah their rabbis and their monks and the Messiah son of Mary, when they were bidden to worship only One God. There is no God save Him. Be He Glorified from all that they ascribe as partner (unto Him)! [Holy Quran, 9:31]

And here is the tafsir [contextual interpretation] of the above verse:

They have taken their rabbis, the scholars among the Jews, and their monks, the devout among the Christians, as lords beside God - following them in making lawful what God has made unlawful and making unlawful what He has made lawful - and the Messiah, son of Mary, when they were not commanded, in the Torah and the Gospel, except to worship One God: there is no god except Him; glory be to Him, as an affirmation of His transcendence [high], above what they associate [with Him]. [9:31]

Altafsir.com – The Tafsirs - ÇáÊÝÇÓíÑ

...`Adi went to the Messenger of Allah wearing a silver cross around his neck. The Messenger of Allah recited this Ayah; "They took their rabbis and their monks to be their lords besides Allah". `Adi commented, "I said, `They did not worship them.''' The Prophet said, "Yes they did. They (rabbis and monks) prohibited the allowed for them (Christians and Jews) and allowed the prohibited, and they obeyed them. This is how they worshipped them".

`Abdullah bin `Abbas and several others said about the explanation of,

(They took their rabbis and their monks to be their lords besides Allah...) that the Christians and Jews obeyed their monks and rabbis in whatever they allowed or prohibited for them. This is why Allah said,

(while they were commanded to worship none but One God), Who, whatever He renders prohibited is the prohibited, whatever He allowed is the allowed, whatever He legislates, is to be the law followed, and whatever He decides is to be adhered to;

(None has the right to be worshipped but He. Hallowed be He above what they associate (with Him).) Meaning, exalted, sanctified, hallowed above partners, equals, aids, rivals or children, there is no deity or Lord worthy of worship except Him.

Tafsir.com Tafsir Ibn Kathir
 
Saltmeister

I am sorry but you seem a little confused.

This in just not true.

I would question anything that you get from that source.

I only said that's what I've heard.

But regardless of whether or not what I heard was true, my point was that the Holy Spirit may not be the same thing in Islam as in Christianity, even though the words are the same. Concerning what Abdullah was saying about associating partners with God, my point was that in Christianity the "Holy Spirit" was not necessarily a separate entity in or apart from God, but was most probably supposed to refer to a "mode of interaction" between God and human beings.

Considering you've told me that what I heard was wrong, could you tell me what "Holy Spirit" really means in Islam?:)

In Islam we have Imams and clerics who interpret the Quran and hadith for us, and we follow them, but what is meant by 'taking them as Lords' is when these 'Leaders' start allowing and prohibiting according to their own accord and not according to what God has revealed, then basically the followers attach to them an attribute which is only fit for God, which is that of the "law maker", and thus they take them as Lords.

I would say this is not how Christianity and Judaism are supposed to work.

It's a bit of a tragedy when religious leaders start trying to control and manipulate the ones they are supposed to guide and enlighten. Sometimes it's only because they're afraid that they'll appear weak if they don't provide us with the answers. They are afraid that if they aren't able to provide us with the answers we want, all the time, non-stop, that people will stop coming to see them.

As a Christian I'd say it's not the ideal in Christianity, and a Jew would probably say the same thing.

The way people may approach a religion is not an indication that that is how a religion really works. Sometimes, due to our limited scope of knowledge, understanding and experience as human beings, we follow the bad example of those around us without evaluating our own actions. This applies to both the leaders and the common people. We get locked into a vicious circle where we try to please and impress our fellow co-religionists. We do this in the belief that this serves the agenda of the religions we follow when we are really just trying to fit in with the rest of the crowd (or mob).

However, in Christianity, there may be an exception with Jesus as he is considered to be Messiah. This makes him special from a Christian point of view. I am aware that Muslims also regard him as Messiah, but the meaning of "Messiah" may be completely different to a Christian as for a Muslim. I have a fair idea of what a Muslim would say about this (surprise me or don't say anything if you're afraid you'll simply blurt out the obvious), so just for now let's just say that ideas and concepts with the same name often have completely different meanings in Islam and Christianity. So Christians come from Mars and Muslims come from Jupiter, or . . . whatever you like.
 
Hi Saltmiester,

I think brother Abu-Bakr may not have heard the Angel Jibreel [Gabriel] being reffered to as "the holy spirit" by Muslims, as generally the angel Jibreel [as] is reffered to by his name [Gibreel] by the Muslim Learned and laymen.

But you are right that in Islam, 'the holy spirit' is believed to be the angel Jibreel [as].

In arabic, the angel gibreel [as] is reffered to as "Ruh ul Qudus', which translates in english as "the holy spirit".

Allah says in ther Quran:

"When Allah saith: O Jesus, son of Mary! Remember My favour unto thee and unto thy mother; how I strengthened thee with the holy Spirit, so that thou speakest unto mankind in the cradle as in maturity..." [5:110]

The Great Muffasireens [qualified interpreters of the Quran] like Ibn Kathir, Al-Jalalayn, Ibn Abbas, Al Tabari, agree that the above mention of "the holy spirit" in verse 5:110, which Allah says he strengthened the prophet Jesus [pbuh] with, was, the angel Jibreel [as].

Also Allah says in Surah 97 - Al Qadr THE NIGHT OF POWER

1 We have indeed revealed this (Message) in the Night of Power:
2 And what will explain to thee what the night of power is?
3 The Night of Power is better than a thousand months.
4 Therein come down the angels and the Spirit by God's permission, on every errand:
5 Peace!...This until the rise of morn!

It can be seen on verse 4 that Allah again refers to 'the spirit',that will decend to the earth, acompanying the angels, and this 'spirit' is regarded as the Arch angel Gibreel [as] by the Islamic Scholars.

Here are the tafsir's of verse 5:110, and verse 97:4:

Mention, when God said, 'O Jesus, son of Mary, remember My favour to you and to your mother, be thankful for it; when I strengthened you with the Holy Spirit, Gabriel, to speak to people in the cradle... [5:110]

Altafsir.com – The Tafsirs - ÇáÊÝÇÓíÑÝÇÓíÑ

The angels and the Spirit, namely, Gabriel, descend in it, on that night, by the leave of their Lord... [97:4]

Altafsir.com – The Tafsirs - ÇáÊÝÇÓíÑ

Peace. :)
 
The Christians and jews regard people of other faiths to be spiritually impure as well, and I suppose the same could be said about the general major faiths out there.

Hope that helps

Peace. :)

While reading my Bible today I ran across a passage that instantly sparked my memory of this specific post. Here's what the passage said:

Peter told them, "You know it is against the Jewish laws for me to come into a Gentile home like this. But God has shown me that I should never think of anyone as impure" (Acts 10:28).
 
Back
Top