There is no such thing as 'Free Will'

"jñeyaḥ sa nitya-sannyāsī yo na dveṣṭi na kāṅkṣati; nirdvandvo hi mahābāho sukhaṃ bandhāt pramucyate."

Know him as ever-renounced one who neither hates nor desires; without any ambiguity in mind, O Arjuna, such person easily gets freed from bonds.
BhagawadGit 5.3
 
Dondi said:
Evil is a consequence of humans having the freewill to choose. But without freewill, there would not be the capacity to love, for love implies a choice.

But then the question is, does God have a freewill? And if so, does He have the capacity to choose evil as well?
Evil in humans is not free-will. It is u[bringing which turns mind in that way.
Hindu God have to pay when they do unjustified things (to compensate, to right the wrong).
 
Don't underestimate other factors. Genetics. Epigenetics. Position in the womb. Childhood illnesses. The list goes on. A person can have wonderful parents and still be a psychopath.
You are right. Genetics can influence people in these ways (DuckAssist):

Summary Table of Genetic Influences
AreaGenetic Influence
BehaviorAggression, social interactions, risk-taking
Mental HealthSusceptibility to disorders like depression
Physical HealthVulnerability to diseases like diabetes and cancer
Environmental ResponseAdaptability to stress, learning, and memory

But that will not constitute free-will if the DNA compels a person to act in a particular way (only an apparent/fake free-will). :)
Now you may say that God decides DNA. That is not my view. IMHO, DNA is decided by what the sperm or ovum bring to the union.
Does a wonderful parent wish to be a psychopath? Something beyond his/her control.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top