Evolution is Unscientific

1718383300746.png

borrowed image in the news this morning
 
Seems topical...

I watched that one, and totally respect Tyson's response

Sabine Hossenfelder also bats Terence Howard aside, and blames Joe Rogan
10 min

 
Last edited:
Genetic drift can introduce new allele frequencies in a population,
How is evolution mathematically possible. Single cell life existed for about the first 1.5 billion years of life on Earth. Organisms did not need to increase in size from 1 to 2 to a 1000 cells.

How did blind nature then go from single cell life, to species with a trillion plus cells? Imagine doing a trillion-piece jigsaw puzzle in 3D of a fish skeleton. You go to the pile, and pick out a thousand pieces, then randomly assemble them. If they are successful, you can add another 1000 pieces, but what happens if there is chaos, do you start again? Could you randomly do this a billion times, and end up with a completed jigsaw puzzle of a fish skeleton? Then repeat for a fifty thousand trillion - piece puzzle for a blue whale.

Numbers tell a story, how is this kind of organisation possible without God?
 
How is evolution mathematically possible. Single cell life existed for about the first 1.5 billion years of life on Earth. Organisms did not need to increase in size from 1 to 2 to a 1000 cells.

How did blind nature then go from single cell life, to species with a trillion plus cells? Imagine doing a trillion-piece jigsaw puzzle in 3D of a fish skeleton. You go to the pile, and pick out a thousand pieces, then randomly assemble them. If they are successful, you can add another 1000 pieces, but what happens if there is chaos, do you start again? Could you randomly do this a billion times, and end up with a completed jigsaw puzzle of a fish skeleton? Then repeat for a fifty thousand trillion - piece puzzle for a blue whale.

Numbers tell a story, how is this kind of organisation possible without God?
Still ignoring scientific facts and adhering to some unproven Sky Daddy myth?

Cells began adhering to each other, creating cell groups that have a higher survival rate, partly because it's harder for predators to kill a group of cells than a single cell.

More than 3 billion years after the appearance of microbes, life got more complicated. Cells organized themselves into new three-dimensional structures. They began to divide up the labor of life, so that some tissues were in charge of moving around, while others managed eating and digesting. They developed new ways for cells to communicate and share resources. These complex multicellular creatures were the first animals, and they were a major success. Soon afterward, roughly 540 million years ago, animal life erupted, diversifying into a kaleidoscope of forms in what’s known as the Cambrian explosion.

 
Still ignoring scientific facts and adhering to some unproven Sky Daddy myth?

Cells began adhering to each other, creating cell groups that have a higher survival rate, partly because it's harder for predators to kill a group of cells than a single cell..
I'm not convinced. 😐

"You find that people cooperate, you say, 'Yeah, that contributes to their genes' perpetuating.' You find that they fight, you say, ‘Sure, that's obvious, because it means that their genes perpetuate and not somebody else's. In fact, just about anything you find, you can make up some story for it."
- Noam Chomsky -
 
Still ignoring scientific facts and adhering to some unproven Sky Daddy myth?

Cells began adhering to each other, creating cell groups that have a higher survival rate, partly because it's harder for predators to kill a group of cells than a single cell.

More than 3 billion years after the appearance of microbes, life got more complicated. Cells organized themselves into new three-dimensional structures. They began to divide up the labor of life, so that some tissues were in charge of moving around, while others managed eating and digesting. They developed new ways for cells to communicate and share resources. These complex multicellular creatures were the first animals, and they were a major success. Soon afterward, roughly 540 million years ago, animal life erupted, diversifying into a kaleidoscope of forms in what’s known as the Cambrian explosion.

To add:
We see in our species and among all kind of species that forming a society is very helpful. This kind of collaboration has developed independently amongst different branches like mankind, ants, tubifex and even trees and fungi who build meta organisms, partly even involving different species. The same principle applies to primitive organisms.
Evolution is not just concurrence, but also, maybe even predominantly, collaboration.
 
How is evolution mathematically possible. Single cell life existed for about the first 1.5 billion years of life on Earth. Organisms did not need to increase in size from 1 to 2 to a 1000 cells.

How did blind nature then go from single cell life, ..? Numbers tell a story, how is this kind of organisation possible without God?
One cell organisms still exist. You can find the details here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multicellular_organism
But why at all should you read that? Why not just stick to Bible, the word of One True God and his son.
I know, you post here just to save us from eternal hell. That is very kind of you.
 
One cell organisms still exist. You can find the details here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multicellular_organism
But why at all should you read that? Why not just stick to Bible, the word of One True God and his son.
I know, you post here just to save us from eternal hell. That is very kind of you.
See, now, that's what I don't understand.

Why bother? You don't agree, you see the world differently (or maybe not as different as you convince yourself) but that doesn't justify condescension. I haven't seen anybody here tell you to go milk a sacred cow.

Do you get some perverse pleasure in ridiculing others? Just because they look at life differently than you?

No other reason is evident. What you are allowing yourself to do is not logical and hardly rational, quite unlike you.
 

Scientists have caught a once-in-a-billion-years evolutionary event in progress, as two lifeforms have merged into one organism that boasts abilities its peers would envy. Last time this happened, Earth got plants.

The phenomenon is called primary endosymbiosis, and it occurs when one microbial organism engulfs another, and starts using it like an internal organ. In exchange, the host cell provides nutrients, energy, protection and other benefits to the symbiote, until eventually it can no longer survive on its own and essentially ends up becoming an organ for the host – or what’s known as an organelle in microbial cells …

In the 4-billion-odd-year history of life on Earth, primary endosymbiosis is thought to have only happened twice that we know of, and each time was a massive breakthrough for evolution. The first occurred about 2.2 billion years ago, when an archaea swallowed a bacterium that became the mitochondria. This specialized energy-producing organelle allowed for basically all complex forms of life to evolve. It remains the heralded "powerhouse of the cell" to this day.

The second time happened about 1.6 billion years ago, when some of these more advanced cells absorbed cyanobacteria that could harvest energy from sunlight. These became organelles called chloroplasts, which gave sunlight-harvesting abilities, as well as a fetching green colour, to a group of lifeforms you might have heard of – plants.

And now, scientists have discovered that it’s happening again. A species of algae called Braarudosphaera bigelowii was found to have engulfed a cyanobacterium that lets them do something that algae, and plants in general, can’t normally do – "fixing" nitrogen straight from the air, and combining it with other elements to create more useful compounds.

Nitrogen is a key nutrient, and normally plants and algae get theirs through symbiotic relationships with bacteria that remain separate. At first it was thought that B. bigelowii had hooked up this kind of situation with a bacterium called UCYN-A, but on closer inspection, scientists discovered that the two have gotten far more intimate …

“That’s one of the hallmarks of something moving from an endosymbiont to an organelle,” said Zehr. “They start throwing away pieces of DNA, and their genomes get smaller and smaller, and they start depending on the mother cell for those gene products – or the protein itself – to be transported into the cell.”

Altogether, the team says this indicates UCYN-A is a full organelle, which is given the name of nitroplast. It appears that this began to evolve around 100 million years ago, which sounds like an incredibly long time but is a blink of an eye compared to mitochondria and chloroplasts.

Read full article ...
 
See, now, that's what I don't understand.
My post was for EricPH. We have tried it so many times to make him understand evolution the science way, but we have failed. So what is the fun in going through all that again? He is welcome to his views and Bible. Why does he need to ask us atheists about evolution, when he has his God's word on that? Genesis 1.11 - 1.31, 2.18 - 2.22 (NIV).
 
It's in the science forum?
 

Scientists have caught a once-in-a-billion-years evolutionary event in progress, as two lifeforms have merged into one organism that boasts abilities its peers would envy. Last time this happened, Earth got plants.

The phenomenon is called primary endosymbiosis, and it occurs when one microbial organism engulfs another, and starts using it like an internal organ. In exchange, the host cell provides nutrients, energy, protection and other benefits to the symbiote, until eventually it can no longer survive on its own and essentially ends up becoming an organ for the host – or what’s known as an organelle in microbial cells …

In the 4-billion-odd-year history of life on Earth, primary endosymbiosis is thought to have only happened twice that we know of, and each time was a massive breakthrough for evolution. The first occurred about 2.2 billion years ago, when an archaea swallowed a bacterium that became the mitochondria. This specialized energy-producing organelle allowed for basically all complex forms of life to evolve. It remains the heralded "powerhouse of the cell" to this day.

The second time happened about 1.6 billion years ago, when some of these more advanced cells absorbed cyanobacteria that could harvest energy from sunlight. These became organelles called chloroplasts, which gave sunlight-harvesting abilities, as well as a fetching green colour, to a group of lifeforms you might have heard of – plants.

And now, scientists have discovered that it’s happening again. A species of algae called Braarudosphaera bigelowii was found to have engulfed a cyanobacterium that lets them do something that algae, and plants in general, can’t normally do – "fixing" nitrogen straight from the air, and combining it with other elements to create more useful compounds.

Nitrogen is a key nutrient, and normally plants and algae get theirs through symbiotic relationships with bacteria that remain separate. At first it was thought that B. bigelowii had hooked up this kind of situation with a bacterium called UCYN-A, but on closer inspection, scientists discovered that the two have gotten far more intimate …

“That’s one of the hallmarks of something moving from an endosymbiont to an organelle,” said Zehr. “They start throwing away pieces of DNA, and their genomes get smaller and smaller, and they start depending on the mother cell for those gene products – or the protein itself – to be transported into the cell.”

Altogether, the team says this indicates UCYN-A is a full organelle, which is given the name of nitroplast. It appears that this began to evolve around 100 million years ago, which sounds like an incredibly long time but is a blink of an eye compared to mitochondria and chloroplasts.

Read full article ...
That is the current dogma...still speculative. It has yet to be demonstrated, therefore is taken on faith. Decades of lab research have come up empty.
 
To add:
We see in our species and among all kind of species that forming a society is very helpful. This kind of collaboration has developed independently amongst different branches like mankind, ants, tubifex and even trees and fungi who build meta organisms, partly even involving different species. The same principle applies to primitive organisms.
Evolution is not just concurrence, but also, maybe even predominantly, collaboration.
How many species of bacteria live inside the gut of any given human being? That's why overuse of antibiotics is so devastating to human health in the long run, those bacteria are necessary and vital to proper digestion.

Got a sniffle? Run to the doctor who prescribes an antibiotic...that is useless against viruses, but wipes out the good gut flora.

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) lives cooperatively in any given human gut, but as the moniker suggests is resistant to antibiotics. Doctor prescribes and patient takes antibiotics, which wipes out the bacterial community that usually keeps the MRSA in check, allowing the MRSA to run rampant...potentially leading to the death of the patient. I have personally experienced this bacterial imbalance, it is not a pleasant experience.

But this is a lesson folks usually learn by experience. I knew what to look for, and why I now challenge doctors who prescribe antibiotics, or I just refuse to take them. Last time I took 3 separate study papers about overuse of antibiotics from different teaching hospitals with me to show the doctor why I was refusing the antibiotics. He didn't like it, but he understood.

Modern medicine is a pill mill. Trauma medicine is fantastic, but chronic disease is one medication after another until one has a grocery list of meds (and no money for food). It is a vicious cycle.
 
Last edited:
no justification for ridicule
That would be the balance between atheist hard-nosed (evidence based) dialogue with theists, in a science section, or atheist mocking and essentially trolling theists on an interfaith platform?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top