Two tests
Nogodnomasters said:
....
Demons my butt.
And us 9 nine year kids who stopped using the Ouija board? We knew when the Gruber boys were moving it because all of a sudden the spirit couldn't spell worth a darn. Want to put a real stopper in the Ouija board nonsense? Just ask it a question neither one who uses the board can answer, but can be easily looked up like, "Spell the Russian word for foot."
All of a sudden your demon is a moron.
Nogo, that's a very good evisceration of the Ouija genie.
I agree with your position that any movements taking place with the Ouija pointer is from the participants, whether knowingly or granting for the sake of argument unknowingly.
But there are still believers who won't accept this explanation; they maintain the movements may come from the participants but are dictated by spirits, demons, or invisible entities. So the genie is still there.
And there are genies who don't know Russian; for genies are like people who might know only one language.
I think we must produce a more versatile stratagem to take away all the refuges of the genie, the method consisting in first allowing that the Ouija genie does indeed exist, but then showing that it is a feeble and ignorant thereby inutile genie; for when it is challenged on knowledge of facts and physical prowess, which are the things really useful in the real world, the genie will certainly flunk.
You have shown how it is ignorant of a simple fact as the word in Russian for shoe. Now, as regards information that is divorced totally from facts, like whether some deceased person is in hell or heaven, the supposed dictation of the genie is gratuitous speculation, bereft of any argumentative force.
What about the feeble strength of the genie? Let's consider again the exercise I described in two earlier posts, about a robust guy pushing the pointer to spell out at least innocuous messages, and being able to overcome any movements from other sources whatever. That shows that the genie if it be present can be overcome by plain muscle power of a guy who is out to discredit him.
These two tests, the one on knowledge of facts and the other on physical power can convince thinking people that even granting some kind of genie be present, it is an inutile genie, good only for amusement; that's why the Ouija Board is a game.
Susma Rio Sep