There is no such thing as 'Free Will'

I am not God. God is not me.

That's another place where we differ.

Buddhists believe that everything is perfect "Buddha Nature". While I don't believe in a God, I think what you describe as God and what I describe as Buddha Nature are the same thing seen from two different points of view.

If that's the case, then I could say that I am God, and God is me. Frankly, I don't see how it could be any other way.

I feel the beneficence of compassion and the peace of wisdom that Buddhists believe to be perfect and all pervasive. They do not exist "outside" of me. They are part of my being and my practice is to fully embody them. Buddhists believe that everyone equally share these gifts but due to delusion (ignorance and ego) lose sight of them.

How could God, all-powerful, eternal and omniscient not be part of you? That would indicate that there are parts of the universe that aren't God. How can something be everywhere, but not in you... not all of you?
 
That's another place where we differ.

Buddhists believe that everything is perfect "Buddha Nature". While I don't believe in a God, I think what you describe as God and what I describe as Buddha Nature are the same thing seen from two different points of view.

If that's the case, then I could say that I am God, and God is me. Frankly, I don't see how it could be any other way.

I feel the beneficence of compassion and the peace of wisdom that Buddhists believe to be perfect and all pervasive. They do not exist "outside" of me. They are part of my being and my practice is to fully embody them. Buddhists believe that everyone equally share these gifts but due to delusion (ignorance and ego) lose sight of them.

How could God, all-powerful, eternal and omniscient not be part of you? That would indicate that there are parts of the universe that aren't God. How can something be everywhere, but not in you... not all of you?

That’s a very nice Buddhist argument. Before I address the specifics, let me make this more general comment:
Since this is the forum on Christianity, I must assume that you are here to investigate the possibility that Christianity, as a system of beliefs, has some kind of valid point. Otherwise, you would be better served to help your fellow Buddhists to more clearly understand their “role”.
There is an essential difference between Buddhism and Christianity. Christians believe that there is, in fact, a single and universal truth, and that whatever denies this truth is, by definition, false. You said earlier that your beliefs were ok for you, and my beliefs were ok for me. I disagree. I believe that your beliefs will inevitably lead to your making a serious and fatal error that will result in an eternity of pain and agony for you.
I believe that what I have tried to explain to you is the truth. Hopefully you will eventually accept and acknowledge it; the truth will not condemn you to eternal separation from a God who loves you, who created you, and who desires to have your company.
Only one of us will turn out to be right.

I have enjoyed our conversation. :)
 
That’s a very nice Buddhist argument. Before I address the specifics, let me make this more general comment:

Since this is the forum on Christianity, I must assume that you are here to investigate the possibility that Christianity, as a system of beliefs, has some kind of valid point. Otherwise, you would be better served to help your fellow Buddhists to more clearly understand their “role”.

Actually, the forum is on interfaith, and if you wanted to stick to solely Christian subject matter perhaps you would be better served posting in a forum solely dedicated to your faith.

I'm attempting to find some commonalities between our two faiths and to understand the differences. And just to be clear, I also have enjoyed our discussions.

But, as a reminder...

Interfaith wikipedia

The terms interfaith or interfaith dialogue refer to cooperative and positive interaction between people of different religious traditions (ie. "faiths") and spiritual or humanistic beliefs, at both the individual and institutional level with the aim of deriving a common ground in belief through a concentration on similarities between faiths, understanding of values, and commitment to the world.
 
There is an essential difference between Buddhism and Christianity. Christians believe that there is, in fact, a single and universal truth, and that whatever denies this truth is, by definition, false. You said earlier that your beliefs were ok for you, and my beliefs were ok for me. I disagree. I believe that your beliefs will inevitably lead to your making a serious and fatal error that will result in an eternity of pain and agony for you.

I believe that what I have tried to explain to you is the truth. Hopefully you will eventually accept and acknowledge it; the truth will not condemn you to eternal separation from a God who loves you, who created you, and who desires to have your company.

Only one of us will turn out to be right.

Thankfully I'm Buddhist! It teaches one how to endure eternities of pain and agony. :p

But seriously, only one person will turn out to be right? How tragic it is that you've come to this point in your spiritual growth! Today I'm wrong for not believing Jesus Christ is my savior, tomorrow Mormons are wrong for believing he ministered Native Americans. Soon the gates to salvation are so small that they only fit people who think exactly like you!

So why did your God make people so different? Just to condemn the majority to eternities of pain and agony? That's a God you can keep company with, but not me. No wonder He hasn't spoken to me lately.

Pattimax, I too believe there is a universal truth. But like a shore of a lake, it does not exist in a single point. One can satisfy one's thirst by traveling from the North, South, East, West and an infinite number of points between. It's not a different truth that we believe in, but different pathways that lead to that truth.
 
The Bible changed the world: built hospitals, freed slaves in the western world, started the civil rights movement, built universities, and changed the calendar…

There have been many horrible things done in its name by misguided people who had not actually read it, but this Holy Book is the source of the USA, the basis of the pursuit of liberty, and the origin of compassion in the western world.

Actually, I believe that many of the people that have done terrible things in the name of the bible have read it. They have simply misread it. With all the languages, and the different versions that the original text, or the closest they could find, have been translated into it is not a hard thing to do. People read things through the filter of their personal reasoning. It's just how the world works.

The bible per se is not the source of the United States. The colonists that came here came to flee religious persecution. They believed in a man's right to practice whatever religion he may choose. There was compassion in the western world long before the bible came along. And before Jesus, it did only a very small part to help foster it. Think of the strict punishments it enforced, the friction between people of different ancestry, and origin. Before Jesus came with the message of love, the bible was a very violent book indeed.

Reading God's Word and believing Him requires no leaps of faith, just a willingness to understand.

I think that you are wrong about this. You cant study yourself into belief in God. It takes faith, and trust. As Citizenzen says, there really is no tangable proof that you can see or learn that will 'light up the bulb above your head' as it were. It is something that you just believe in, know without learning, and in that way is much stronger than any learned knowledge.

Contemporary commentary can certainly help people to relate to the writings of a holy book. Modern Bible commentators do so with great care to neither add to nor take away any of the scripture, so as to prevent it becoming a written game of "telephone".

Lol. My wording has rubbed off I see. ;) When I say that though, I don't mean to take away from the actual original text. Just the subsequent generations I feel are not on par with the original. I don't see how it could be after being mucked about with so much, even with the best intentions.
You know the quote about what the road to hell is paved with... J/k. I don't even believe in hell as most christians do. But it was funny nontheless.

How could God, all-powerful, eternal and omniscient not be part of you? That would indicate that there are parts of the universe that aren't God. How can something be everywhere, but not in you... not all of you?

Citizenzen, I have been told recently by Thomas that Christians have some different definition of omnipotent and omniscient than either I or Webster do... Maybe this is part of the problem. I don't see how it makes sense either. ;)

Christians believe that there is, in fact, a single and universal truth, and that whatever denies this truth is, by definition, false. You said earlier that your beliefs were ok for you, and my beliefs were ok for me. I disagree. I believe that your beliefs will inevitably lead to your making a serious and fatal error that will result in an eternity of pain and agony for you.
I believe that what I have tried to explain to you is the truth. Hopefully you will eventually accept and acknowledge it; the truth will not condemn you to eternal separation from a God who loves you, who created you, and who desires to have your company.
Only one of us will turn out to be right.

Well, you are entitled to your beliefs.

I believe that God created the world with all of it's religions for a purpose. And to say that he created certain people, knowing that they would believe in these different religions (that he created mind you,) and knowing that, he would throw them into an eternal hell for doing something that he knew they were going to do anyway, makes no sense to me.

You would probably agree that God created man. You would probably agree that God created everything on this earth. You would probably agree that he is omniscient, omnipotent, and omnipresent.

And then you would probably still go against all reason and agree with an eternal hell, that the concept of is not even plainly stated in the bible, if it is alluded to at all, which is debatable.

You can believe what you do. You can believe it is the only truth. And seeing it through that filter, I realize that you can do little less than try to evangelize on a forum that is here for sharing views. But if you are really so sure about your beliefs, I would say that evangelizing is the only reason for your presence here. And that is not what this site is about, unless I have misunderstood, which I doubt.

We're all here to learn, and see the world through other people's filters for a bit. Maybe you could give it a try. That's all I wanted to say.

Sorry to barge in! :eek: See ya!
 
Citizenzen, I didn't know that you were Buddhist from our earlier conversations. I think that life being all about the learning process is very true, and I cannot think of a better meaning in life than to grow in all things, and all understanding. Well, I learn something new every day. Maybe even more than one thing on a good day, lol.

See ya!
 
Hey, I just had a thought, and I thought that I'd throw it out on the debate sounding board. The title of this thread is, There is no such thing as 'free will.' Well, I was thinking about that, and something smacked me in the face suddenly.:p

If you do not believe in God, then using the term 'free will' doesn't make any sense. Semantically, as it were. Who's will are you free from?

Random thought. :D
 
Hey, I just had a thought, and I thought that I'd throw it out on the debate sounding board. The title of this thread is, There is no such thing as 'free will.' Well, I was thinking about that, and something smacked me in the face suddenly.:p

If you do not believe in God, then using the term 'free will' doesn't make any sense. Semantically, as it were. Who's will are you free from?

Random thought. :D
There are others (bullies, rapists, etc) who would compel and/or force you to do something you don't want.
 
Hey, I just had a thought, and I thought that I'd throw it out on the debate sounding board. The title of this thread is, There is no such thing as 'free will.' Well, I was thinking about that, and something smacked me in the face suddenly.:p

If you do not believe in God, then using the term 'free will' doesn't make any sense. Semantically, as it were. Who's will are you free from?

Random thought. :D

There are others (bullies, rapists, etc) who would compel and/or force you to do something you don't want.

But that's hardly how 'free will' is used in this thread. Tricky, tricky. Lol. :p I'm onto you. :D
There are those who are deluded into thinking that they are God. (See 2 Thess 2.)
 

Now this is truly meaningless…If a Zen-master asks a meaningless question (koan) and there are no students around to be befuddled, is he still wise?

Of whom is the Zen master asking a question?:confused:

s.
 
Where does this leave the starving, the unsheltered and the down-trodden?

s.

We are commanded to be the hands and feet of Christ, to feed the hungry, clothe the naked, and care for widows, orphans, and the stranger. Where it leaves them, is entirely up to each one of US. God will provide for their needs, and calls upon us to be the delivery system.
 
Where does this leave the starving, the unsheltered and the down-trodden?

s.
Now that is a loaded question. What with pattimax doing what she can to help others and my going out to try and save lives at sea...that leaves...you...
 
This IS the Christianity page.

I had the wrong idea about this forum. I had no idea this was a place where Christians were not permitted to explain their faith. Rather, this is a place where you all come to congratulate each other on being so much smarter than us, while you repeatedly misrepresent us and the God you do not believe in.
The condemnation, my dear friends, is all yours. Enjoy your eternity in darkness. Take care that you don’t actually read this Bible you are so knowledgeable about. And I, too, am glad you have prepared so thoroughly for an eternity of pain and agony.

 
Actually, the forum is on interfaith, and if you wanted to stick to solely Christian subject matter perhaps you would be better served posting in a forum solely dedicated to your faith.
Um, CZ, she did, and this is (the christian forum), and you seem to have missed that small point...but I didn't.

remember how you said you had to work on your, um, ways...this is one of those times....
 
This IS the Christianity page.

I had the wrong idea about this forum. I had no idea this was a place where Christians were not permitted to explain their faith. Rather, this is a place where you all come to congratulate each other on being so much smarter than us, while you repeatedly misrepresent us and the God you do not believe in.
The condemnation, my dear friends, is all yours. Enjoy your eternity in darkness. Take care that you don’t actually read this Bible you are so knowledgeable about. And I, too, am glad you have prepared so thoroughly for an eternity of pain and agony.
Actually it is...CZ kinda missed the boat, that's all...he's working on it.
 
So why did your God make people so different? Just to condemn the majority to eternities of pain and agony? That's a God you can keep company with, but not me. No wonder He hasn't spoken to me lately.

John 3:17-20 says that people are condemned by their own choice. Christians believe that the death of Christ on the cross paid the penalty for the sins of all humanity, for all time (since Adam, until the end of the world). This solution to the problem of sin preserves God's demand for justice (who would want an unjust God?). It goes on to say, however, that there are those who would prefer to reject this act of mercy, in order to continue to behave badly. These people condemn themselves to darkness because in the dark their deeds will not be known.
A God who loves me so much to make a way back to the light for me is a God I can keep company with!
 
Back
Top