Are you a Christian?

Postmaster

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,312
Reaction score
3
Points
0
The identical thing that we now call Christian religion existed among the ancients, and has not been lacking from the beginning of the human race leading to the coming of Christ in the flesh, from which moment on the true religion, which already existed, began to be called Christian.

Saint Augustine


Is he saying that people who bahave a certain way are following a Christian path? Does one need to consider themselves Christian to follow this path? Do people who consider themselves Christian sometimes not follow this path?
 
I believe he is saying that Jesus was able to formulate sentences and stories that allowed more people to see universal truths. and to answer your inquiry, imo yes, yes and no.(oops yes)
 
Last edited:
"The identical thing that we now call Christian religion existed among the ancients, and has not been lacking from the beginning of the human race leading to the coming of Christ in the flesh, from which moment on the true religion, which already existed, began to be called Christian." Saint Augustine
It would be useful if you could cite the source of the quote, so we can look at it in context. I have Googled it, and find a (false) attribution on a site calling itself 'The Liberal Catholic Church', and on 'Joseph's Almighty Site' it is attributed to The City of God, but I cannot find the sentence in the text ... si I am inclined to think this is somewhat spurious.

As Christians believe that Christ is the Logos, then any who seeks truth, reality, goodness etc, seeks, without knowing it, Christ. So there were, as Clement of Alexandria called them 'anonymous Christians' before Christ, and there are still today, 'anonymous' in the sense that Christ is unknown to them, as He would be to the world, but for the Apostles, and those who follow their teachings.

Is he saying that people who behave a certain way are following a Christian path? Does one need to consider themselves Christian to follow this path? Do people who consider themselves Christian sometimes not follow this path?
Yes ... yes ... yes ...

Yes 1:
They love God and their neighbour ...

Yes 2:
Depends what path you're talking about. Being good? No. To love God and neighbour? No. To enter the Higher Mysteries? Yes.

Yes 3:
Tragically ... but such is the way with humanity.

Thomas
 
No such thing as a true Christian, post - Nope nadda one! But, there are some who think themselves to be such. Regardless of ones belief and dedication to Christ, we all fall short in the end. The truth is that we are all in the same boat. It doesn't matter our beliefs, or our life style - We are all damaged goods. Even so, Christ died for all men, and when we stand before him on judgement day each of us will fall to our knees in awe of His mercy, and the love he has for each of us.

I guess if I had to define a Christian - "I" would say that it is one who realizes that there are none better than another, and one who leans on Christ in all things. A Christian is one who knows that the convict on death row is no worse than the preacher in the pulpit. It is one who has enough faith in Christ to know that He is bigger than our religious ideologies, and our self righteous attitudes. I know of no man who fits this criteria, and lives it - Nope nadda one! (Including myself)

Nope I'm NOT what I view a Christian to be, but I do 'try' to follow Christ ....

GK
 
No such thing as a true Christian, post - Nope nadda one!
Really? Not one? Then the whole thing's a pointless endeavour, is it not?

A Christian is one who is a follower of Christ, that does not mean he or she is Christ, but follows Christ ... are they perfect? No. Does Christ expect them to be? No. Does Christ call them to perfection? Yes.

So what is required, to be a Christian? The determination to go just that little bit further, for Christ's sake.

But, there are some who think themselves to be such.
For His sake, I call myself a Christian. Do I set myself as the standard by which He is judged? No. But if it weren't for those like me, who call ourselves Christian, then the world would never have heard of Him, would it?

Regardless of ones belief and dedication to Christ, we all fall short in the end.
Of course. We all know that, but because we love Him, we try anyway. That's a big difference between not trying but depending on His love for us ... and frankly, that's not a good bargaining position, because it boders on hypocrisy, and that's the one thing he had no time for.

The truth is that we are all in the same boat. It doesn't matter our beliefs, or our life style - We are all damaged goods.
You've missed the point. It's not the boat we're in, its the effort we make.

Even so, Christ died for all men, and when we stand before him on judgement day each of us will fall to our knees in awe of His mercy, and the love he has for each of us.
OK. But if you've made no effort in your life, but just bargained on His mercy and forgiveness, that's pretty phoney, don't you think?

I mean, suppose the amount of mercy is a correlate of the amount of effort made ... you'd be in real trouble then, surely ...

I guess if I had to define a Christian - "I" would say that it is one who realizes that there are none better than another, and one who leans on Christ in all things.
Oh, there's more to it than that ... there's obeying His commandments, there's participation in the Sacraments He established ... and to assume that we're all the same is the same as assuming no-one is better than me, which is pride, and that's a bad thing. Humility, on the other hand, always hopes that I might learn something from my brother, whereas you seem to be saying there's nothing anyone can teach you ... I'm sure you're not, but that's how it reads ...

A Christian is one who knows that the convict on death row is no worse than the preacher in the pulpit.
Tosh! Then Christ has no morals, no standards, no values ... which is patently not true.

It is one who has enough faith in Christ to know that He is bigger than our religious ideologies, and our self righteous attitudes.
That's why Christians profess His ideology and not their own ... only in recent times have pseudo-Christians taken to inventing their own ideologies, and calling them Christian, under the self-righteous illusion that if it suits them, it'll suit Christ ... and then accusing everyone else of following a man-made ideology!

I know of no man who fits this criteria, and lives it - Nope nadda one! (Including myself)
Then either you've got your eyes shut, your judgement of humanity is based on your own low self-esteem, or you've got your criteria wrong. I suggest the latter.

Thomas
 
Really? Not one? Then the whole thing's a pointless endeavour, is it not?

What endeavor, Thomas? Millions call themselves Christian, but very few walk the walk they claim is necessary, and that is my point. We are hypocrites, liars, and most have no idea what it means to be a 'true' christian, or follower of Christ.
A Christian is one who is a follower of Christ, that does not mean he or she is Christ, but follows Christ ... are they perfect? No. Does Christ expect them to be? No. Does Christ call them to perfection? Yes.
That would be one definition, but who on earth truly follows Him?

So what is required, to be a Christian? The determination to go just that little bit further, for Christ's sake.
For Christ's sake? No, Christ came so we might have an abundant life, and that is what most are missing. He came for our sake, not His. God gave us life, Christ showed us how to live it. Christian principle and God's law are there for our benefit, but again, who on earth truly follows Christ?


For His sake, I call myself a Christian. Do I set myself as the standard by which He is judged? No. But if it weren't for those like me, who call ourselves Christian, then the world would never have heard of Him, would it?
For His sake again? Man, I think it's all about mankind becoming better beings - Happy, joyous, serene, content, and full of peace. Christ is perfect, and He showed us how to aim for the perfection He embodies. I love Christ with all my heart, but I also know that when I do things for him I am missing the mark. He desires that we learn from Him, so we might grow as a species. All for us, bro!


Of course. We all know that, but because we love Him, we try anyway. That's a big difference between not trying but depending on His love for us ... and frankly, that's not a good bargaining position, because it boders on hypocrisy, and that's the one thing he had no time for.
There is no 'try' in reality, there is only do, lol. If we follow Him, we are doing what is not only best for us, but also what is best for this world. God so loved the world ...

You've missed the point. It's not the boat we're in, its the effort we make.
Nope, it's not about human effort, it is about the journey itself, and what we learn on the way. All our efforts are vain, as it is Christ that gives us the ability to overcome our weaknesses. We ARE in the same boat, Thomas. If not, then Christ died in vain ...


OK. But if you've made no effort in your life, but just bargained on His mercy and forgiveness, that's pretty phoney, don't you think?
When we take on Christ, He makes His dwelling in us - He makes the change He desires, our only charge is to want the change that He can, and will make in us when we are willing to 'truly' follow His lead.

The world is full of phonies, sure. The world is full of those who talk a good talk, but when it comes to walking according to what they themselves preach they fall short everytime. We are not perfect, but we are called to follow Christ in all we do. Who does this? No one!
I mean, suppose the amount of mercy is a correlate of the amount of effort made ... you'd be in real trouble then, surely ...
Faith w/o works is dead, we are to show our faith in our works, but works has little to do with effort. It comes naturally when we take on Christ - He makes His dwelling in us giving us the ability to follow Him. The problem is that most are waiting for His return, when He is already in our midst.


Oh, there's more to it than that ... there's obeying His commandments, there's participation in the Sacraments He established ... and to assume that we're all the same is the same as assuming no-one is better than me, which is pride, and that's a bad thing. Humility, on the other hand, always hopes that I might learn something from my brother, whereas you seem to be saying there's nothing anyone can teach you ... I'm sure you're not, but that's how it reads ...
To assume that we are all the same is to be humble enough to know that I'm no better than you, nor you me. We are in the same boat, and Christ is the Captain of that boat. It doesn't matter what we've done in the end, or how long we labor, we all get the same wages. *Thinks of parable of the land owner*

Tosh! Then Christ has no morals, no standards, no values ... which is patently not true.
If you don't think that Christ died for the prisoner on death row, and you truly believe that you are better than that convict, then you have an issue of pride, self righteousness, faith and Christ died in vain when it comes to that individual. He's bigger than we are, Thomas and His grace extends to all men in the end ....


That's why Christians profess His ideology and not their own ... only in recent times have pseudo-Christians taken to inventing their own ideologies, and calling them Christian, under the self-righteous illusion that if it suits them, it'll suit Christ ... and then accusing everyone else of following a man-made ideology!
He is far bigger than most believe - Who is lacking in faith here? The one who knows and believes with their heart that Christ came for all men, and that all men will be saved in the end, or those who believe their works, and personal efforts get them in heaven. Christ did NOT die in vain - He has reconciled us to the Father, and we will all be saved. I believe it. ;)


Then either you've got your eyes shut, your judgement of humanity is based on your own low self-esteem, or you've got your criteria wrong. I suggest the latter.

Thomas
There is good news! "After the game, the king and the pawn go into the same box." -Italian Proverb

My self esteem would prob be considered arrogance to some, lol. (Not sure why you think it is low) Maybe because pride of self has got you thinking you are better than others? What is the criteria? We are sinners, we all fall short, and Christ came so we might have life, and have that life in abundance. *That's the criteria* AND the "Good News".

GK
 
What endeavor, Thomas? Millions call themselves Christian, but very few walk the walk they claim is necessary, and that is my point.
I just think you're professing a very unChristian sentiment. Christ is love personified. He's forgiveness personified, He's generosity personified, He's mercy personified. He's hope personified. He's humility personified, He's grace personified ... and I don't see it in your commentary on the human condition. All I see is the reverse.

If your message is true, then mankind would have given up hope long, long ago.

Thomas
 
I just think you're professing a very unChristian sentiment. Christ is love personified. He's forgiveness personified, He's generosity personified, He's mercy personified. He's hope personified. He's humility personified, He's grace personified ... and I don't see it in your commentary on the human condition. All I see is the reverse.

If your message is true, then mankind would have given up hope long, long ago.

Thomas

What is un Christian about hope for all people? What is un Christian about His love for each of us (regardless of what we've done)? What is un Christian about forgiveness, or the mercy I view Him to extend to all mankind? What is un Christian about having the humility to know and understand that no one is better or worse than anyone else?

Thomas, there is hope in Christ - Not only in the hereafter, but also in the now. We just need to allow Him to guide us, bro ... He can make us a better peoples. If we truly followed Him, our lives would reflect His amazing grace, just as it would reflect the light He shines upon each of us. Pay attention, as He dwells within the body of mankind, ruling from the heart of each individual.

GK
 
wow.. both of you are in the same place and believing the same thing.. each just has a different way of wording the wonderful mercy and grace we have recieved. From the outside looking on you both were saying the same thing.. just differently.

All I saw in that GK's focus was that our "old man" spoke of in romans can never be a true Christian.. and Thomas basically saying as new creations we are made new in the image of Christ so we are good enough. Our struggle everyday is to keep that "old man" down and to live in the spirit which is the image of Christ.

I would say... dont focus so much on that old man GK.... We are to be humble but not to the point we cannot grow in the spirit with our new liberty. Its a stronghold to be so defeated. We have victory over that death praise to the Lord.

As believers in our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.. we are redeemed and there is no condemnation to those in Him and we ARE co-heirs to His throne by the grace of God. So praise Him and be thankful in ALL things.
 
From eternal seperation and damnation. The blood of Christ has saved me and I will forever be with the Lord and in paradise when this life has passed.
You were never d@mned in the first place.
Separation from God/Source exists only in your mind.
Jesus is a placebo.
I used to believe the same line you do, but thankfully I have been saved from such myth-conceptions.
But if it makes you feel good about yourself and your life then by all means...enjoy.
 
You were never d@mned in the first place.
Separation from God/Source exists only in your mind.
Jesus is a placebo.

Well, it's a bit more complicated than that in my mind, but all things considered, yes. Jesus is a placebo. He is also many, many more things.

One of those things is a living breathing model of how we should live our lives. No matter how you see the whole "Jesus saved me from myself" thing you can still look at the teachings, and the life of Jesus, and learn from it.

You don't have to believe in the whole to see wisdom in a part of that whole.

And you can't be seperated from God. That seems a very silly concept to me. God is in all that he created, and the thought of one of his creations somehow finding somewhere that God isn't seems impossible at the least.

My two shiny pennies worth. Don't spend it all in one place. ;)
 
I oversimplified it a bit, but that is my learned opinion and I do have extensive christian experience.
I think that people can learn how to be good people from pretty much any religion, so I don't really knock them as that is a good thing, but people get all dogmatic about their beliefs and insist that they alone have the truth when the truth they are peddling is not beneficial which would include any of the "carrot of heaven and stick of hell" brand.
It is the political consequences of these religions on a societal level which is of concern to me as people then are subject to having their consent steered in quite detrimental directions....detrimental for people in general.
 
Ah, yes. Religion, the bane of free will.

But everything is going according to plan. Even if it seems bad, who are we to judge what bad really is. I leave the creation up to the creator, and just try to learn what I may in the time that I am given.
 
Back
Top