RubySera_Martin
Well-Known Member
I've come to the end of the thread at last. Taijasi, your post leaves me exhausted. There is so MUCH in it. Thanks, everyone, for sharing.
Ruby
Ruby
...which could be an explaination as to why such gifts are said to be temporary in 1 Corinthians 13:8....cavalier said:My worry is that charismatic behavior is a distraction away from God, rather than something which might bring us closer.
seattlegal said:...which could be an explaination as to why such gifts are said to be temporary in 1 Corinthians 13:8....
It would we who draw away from God. Notice how these charisms are compared the traits of children:cavalier said:I would argue that if this charismatic behavior took us farther from God that it would not be one of the Gifts of the Spirit, but would have another source.
If we draw away from our faith, hope, and God's love, then these charisms become empty, or idolatrous, as path_of_one pointed out.1 Corinthians 13 said:4 Love suffers long and is kind; love does not envy; love does not parade itself, is not puffed up; 5 does not behave rudely, does not seek its own, is not provoked, thinks no evil; 6 does not rejoice in iniquity, but rejoices in the truth; 7 bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things.
8 Love never fails. But whether there are prophecies, they will fail; whether there are tongues, they will cease; whether there is knowledge, it will vanish away. 9 For we know in part and we prophesy in part. 10 But when that which is perfect has come, then that which is in part will be done away.
11 When I was a child, I spoke as a child, I understood as a child, I thought as a child; but when I became a man, I put away childish things. 12 For now we see in a mirror, dimly, but then face to face. Now I know in part, but then I shall know just as I also am known.
13 And now abide faith, hope, love, these three; but the greatest of these is love.
I wouldn't say that these charisms are not from God, but these charisms can show just whose children we want to be....1 Corinthians 13 said:1 Though I speak with the tongues of men and of angels, but have not love, I have become sounding brass or a clanging cymbal. 2 And though I have the gift of prophecy, and understand all mysteries and all knowledge, and though I have all faith, so that I could remove mountains, but have not love, I am nothing. 3 And though I bestow all my goods to feed the poor, and though I give my body to be burned, but have not love, it profits me nothing.
4 Love suffers long and is kind; love does not envy; love does not parade itself, is not puffed up; 5 does not behave rudely, does not seek its own, is not provoked, thinks no evil; 6 does not rejoice in iniquity, but rejoices in the truth; 7 bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things.
RubySera_Martin said:I think you must be talking about a special kind of discernment. The word "discern" in the everyday sense simply means the intellectual function of figuring out which is the best of two different options, to notice something--pick up information such as a barely visible object--from its surrounding background, etc.
I have always understood spiritual discernment as meaning to differentiate between the good and evil spirits. Empathetic discernment would probably be to become aware of another person's unspoken and invisible condition of emotions or body or spirit.
For a person who does not normally pick up on these things it might possibly appear like a mysterious and powerful thing to be feared and reckoned with. But for a person for whom this is natural I don't think anyone need to attach any supernatural values to it at all. It's simply being aware of psychological nuances and how they are expressed.
In other words, the signals are not invisible and unexpressed. They are expressed visibly or audibly or via pattern of thought or behaviour that is quite obvious to anyone who is awake and aware of this level of nuance. It might be necessary to realize that others are not the same as you. The person who thinks that "everybody's like me and anybody's who's not is wierd" is not going to see it.
Learning to recognize and correctly identify these nuances is a life-long task. Thus, the idea that discernment is like life--either you have it or you don't--is incorrect. Just put yourself inside the other person's skin, mindset, emoting habits, etc., and you're ready to start learning.
cavalier said:Dondi, I was interested that you said you didn't put a lot of stock in speaking in tongues. All my experiences with this before have been with people who did put a lot of stock in it. I had assumed that everyone who spoke in tongues in the "charismatic sense" felt this way about they were doing. Now I know better. and yes, my brother is a devout Christian, not particularly charismatic, he would certainly never speak in tongues in this sense while at church.
Path, you said that everything is spiritual for you, I can understand that, in fact that idea came to me as I was writing my post last night. From what you wrote though, it seems that you are celebrating life, that you have a heightened state of awareness. I would suggest that my brother was experiencing something entirely different. He was celebrating his idol, his Golden Calf, Liverpool FC.
Ok, as both you and Ruby's friend have stated, charismatic behavior is not limited to Christians. It could still be the Holy Spirit which moves people but in most cases I just don't buy it. Were those Israelites who worshipped the Golden Calf moved by the Holy Spirit? I don't think so. They were moved by something though, perhaps the same thing that moved my brother that day, and I believe, the same thing which moves many people in charismatic churches around the world.
My worry is that charismatic behavior is a distraction away from God, rather than something which might bring us closer.
I agree.path_of_one said:One can have an experience or emotion (ecstasy) without it being from either God or Satan. My point is that it can just be a response to the energy of a crowd, a place, whatever.
I agree, didn't I write pretty much the same thing in my first post on this topic?path_of_one said:My guess is that your brother got caught up in the wave of energy from the crowd, and this brought on the altered state.
That's exactly my point. I don't think it's Satanic either.path_of_one said:I hate to say it, but the feeling I've gotten in many mega-churches during impassioned sermons calling people to convert, and the resulting chaotic jumble of emotions and rush to the altar, are not much different from the feeling I've gotten in many a rock concert, sporting event, or other secular activity where emotions and energy runs high and crowds "feed" off each other.
Exactly, this is the point, so many people believe that this feeling is of God that it will for them get in the way.path_of_one said:it can become an obstacle to our relationship with God IF we put it before God.
Namaste Thomas,Thomas said:This is where religious experience 'for real' occurs, and it lies beyond the capacity of the collective or the individual to induce it.
To suggest that LSD and the Holy Spirit are synonymous is ludicrous nonsense, and to likewise suggest that one might as well pop a tab of acid as pursue a virtuous life is contemptible.
cavalier said:Exactly, this is the point, so many people believe that this feeling is of God that it will for them get in the way.
Quahom1 said:Ok, so we've "touched" on speaking in tongues, and spiritual discernment, five more to go...how about healing?
Thank you, in your demonstration of skill, tact, diplomacy and charity, for reminding me of a prayer that is applicable here, Thomas:Thomas said:As Christian doctrine has once again been grossly misrepresented I feel it might serve some purpose to try and clarify the mess ...
And here I thought Christians typically prayed to Christ Jesus regarding how THEY MIGHT SERVE, and not how they might BE SERVED. I guess I was wrong. Interesting, since the `Unification Mantram' uttered by esotericists also begins:Thomas said:it is also the grave danger of seeking 'spirit guides' and the like who attach themselves to you, supposedly in service, whilst all the time feeding ...
In terms of our inability to "induce" REAL religious experience, I fundamentally disagree. Yes, I think it is beyond the power of ANY person to simply snap his or her fingers and "get G-d's attention" ... AS IF that's what it was all about. Nor are most people skilled at going into deepest trance. But the four yogic states of consciousness to which George Harrison referred - Jagrat, Svapna, Sushupti and Turiya - are objective, and can be entered by those who are properly trained. It TAKES a Masters to TRAIN a Master. This has EVER been the rule.Thomas said:This is where religious experience 'for real' occurs, and it lies beyond the capacity of the collective or the individual to induce it.
To suggest that LSD and the Holy Spirit are synonymous is ludicrous nonsense, and to likewise suggest that one might as well pop a tab of acid as pursue a virtuous life is contemptible.
Thomas
No worriespath_of_one said:Sorry, cavalier, I think I misunderstood you.
Agreed.path_of_one said:I think the feeling can be from God, but isn't always from God.
taijasi said:Appeal to "God in the Highest," if you like - for example of such a Master, but be careful where you draw the line. I do understand that many Christians choose not to recognize other fully capable Masters besides Christ Jesus. That is a choice and an option available to the Christian, just as the Sikh, the Brahmin, the Sufi, or the Buddhist bhikku makes his own choice ... as to which Master to acknowledge, and Serve and follow.
Yes, Dondi. I entered the caveat explicity because this is the Christian forum. But keep in mind, Christians aren't the only ones who believe in Jesus as a spiritual Master. NOR does one have to be a Hindu, or a Buddhist, or a Muslim, wherein St. Issa is recognized - yet viewed as one of many. As an esotericist, it is up to me to learn to distinguish between the various Masters ... but it would be quite presumptuous for me to INFORM you that "you should believe in" or "direct your attention to" another Master than Christed Jesus. And it is EQUALLY presumptuous and absurd for a Christian to suggest to a non-Christian that Jesus is the only or highest Master, or that `Gifts of the Spirit' is something that applies only to Christians.Dondi said:Of course, you realize that the majority of Christians believe Jesus to be God in the Flesh as the only begotten Son of God, and therefore is the only "Master" with which they have to do. Even if there are other "Masters", to quote the cliche, "Why go anywhere else?" To have Jesus as a master, teacher, guide, etc. is about as high as you are gonna get.